1. Customer Experience & Communication
-
A recurring theme throughout the comments is the level of customer service provided by Franklin Colletta and his team. Several reviewers make specific references to how personable and supportive Franklin is. This type of feedback is particularly valuable when assessing a company’s overall reputation and customer satisfaction.
For example:
-
Stacy S (Virginia) says, “Thank you! You are a prince! I don’t know what wizardry you performed between him not negotiating and today but what a load off!” This comment suggests that Franklin or the team performed some form of negotiation or behind-the-scenes work that turned around a previously unyielding situation with Integon Insurance Company. The praise here goes beyond just the appraisal report itself, highlighting an added level of negotiation or consulting support that some appraisal companies might not provide.
-
Tania M (California) also shares that she felt confident and empowered going into her small claims hearing thanks to Franklin’s guidance. This is crucial because it shows that the company doesn’t just provide reports but also offers strategic support, walking clients through the claims or legal process as needed.
Deeper Analysis:
The ability to provide consultation and support beyond just the appraisal could be a key differentiator for The St. Lucie Appraisal Company. It’s not just about providing numbers; they seem to actively participate in supporting the client’s strategy for getting the best settlement.
2. The Effectiveness of Appraisal Reports
-
Joseph P (California) describes how the appraisal company helped him secure 2.5 times the original offer from his insurance company, which emphasizes the effectiveness of the reports.
-
Doug K (California) also mentions a significant improvement in his settlement, from a $3,915.00 offer to $8,000 after using their services.
Deeper Analysis:
-
The quality and reliability of the appraisal reports seem to be a major strength. The fact that these reports were able to hold up even when challenged by large insurers (like Geico or Progressive) speaks volumes about the thoroughness and professionalism of the appraisers.
-
This also suggests that the company uses a well-researched methodology, pulling data from reliable sources (such as dealerships, market data, and sometimes even comparable vehicles) to justify their valuations. This could be one of the reasons why clients feel confident challenging lowball offers from insurance companies.
Takeaway: If you’re dealing with a challenging insurance company that seems to lowball your claim, strong documentation and the backing of a reputable appraisal service like this can make a significant difference.
3. The Impact on Insurance Settlements
-
A number of customers share how the diminished value report directly influenced their settlements:
-
Joseph V (Kansas) mentions how he settled without needing further calls with the appraisal company after sending the report, which is a testament to the clarity and power of the appraisal.
-
Linda C (Florida) describes how the appraisal helped her avoid losing money when trading in her car. This suggests that diminished value reports are not only helpful for insurance claims but also valuable in other car-related financial decisions (such as trade-ins or resale).
-
Deeper Analysis:
-
The fact that these reports can lead to quicker settlements or better offers from insurance companies indicates the value of having a trusted appraisal service in the process. In some cases, it seems that just submitting the report, without needing further negotiation, is enough to prompt the insurance company to re-evaluate their initial low offer.
-
This means that the appraisal company’s influence goes beyond just documenting the vehicle’s diminished value; they appear to have enough expertise and credibility to pressure insurance companies into offering more reasonable settlements.
4. The Role of Franklin Colletta
-
The name Franklin Colletta comes up frequently in these reviews, and it’s clear he plays a central role in delivering these positive experiences. He is described as both an expert in diminished value appraisals and a genuine, caring professional.
-
Tania M (California) writes, “Your detailed diminished value report and your willingness to take the time to walk me through each step were absolutely invaluable.” This suggests that Franklin’s involvement goes beyond the technical aspects of the appraisal, extending into a more personal and hands-on approach.
-
Deeper Analysis:
-
Franklin’s direct involvement and personal touch in guiding clients through the often-frustrating claims process could be a significant part of why customers have such a positive perception. His willingness to offer advice on legal matters and to walk clients through their next steps helps foster trust, which is critical when clients are dealing with often-complex insurance negotiations or claims processes.
-
This kind of customer interaction might also contribute to high retention rates, with customers likely returning for future services or referring others to the company.
5. The Pricing Structure
-
Mike L (Oklahoma) notes that they “cannot imagine things going better,” and Joseph V (Kansas) directly mentions the price of the appraisal service being $275 for his report, which resulted in a $3,100 diminished value claim.
-
Jachelle P (California) mentions how her appraisal came in at $5,475, while Geico offered just $4,000.
Deeper Analysis:
-
The pricing of $275 for a diminished value appraisal seems reasonable, considering the potential return on investment (ROI) clients report. If a client is able to secure an additional $2,000 to $5,000 in their settlement, paying for the appraisal appears to be a worthwhile investment.
-
Affordability and value for money are highlighted in several reviews, particularly because the service helps clients maximize their compensation from insurance companies, often by amounts that far exceed the cost of the appraisal.
6. Frustrations & Potential Areas for Improvement
-
Although most reviews are positive, some comments hint at frustrations with the insurance companies (like Geico offering lowball settlements initially) or difficulties in dealing with inconsistent offers (e.g., Rachit M with Progressive).
-
Jachelle P is unsure whether to accept a $4,000 offer or push for more, which shows that while the appraisal service is strong, the negotiation process with insurance companies can still involve some uncertainty or challenges.
Deeper Analysis:
-
This frustration is not unique to this company; it’s part of the broader insurance claims process, where companies often attempt to offer less than the actual diminished value to save money.
-
However, the fact that the appraisal service seems to provide reliable reports and support, and even prepares clients for court (as in Sue J’s case), positions them well to navigate these challenges effectively.
Final Takeaways:
-
The St. Lucie Appraisal Company stands out in the auto appraisal industry for offering detailed, well-supported diminished value reports that help clients achieve higher settlements.
-
Their personalized customer service (particularly from Franklin Colletta) is a significant factor in the positive feedback.
-
Pricing is reasonable compared to the value that clients report receiving, making this service a strong investment for anyone dealing with a diminished value claim.
-
Challenges with insurers remain a part of the process, but the company’s expertise and negotiation support give customers an edge in these tough situations.
In short, the overall feedback from these reviews paints a picture of a trusted, professional service that not only offers high-quality appraisals but also goes above and beyond to help clients navigate the often tricky insurance claims process.
Click on the payment button above to pay by Credit Card or Paypal. The fee for an Automobile Diminished Value Report is
$275.00. You may also make your Credit Card Payment by telephone, call 772-359-4300.
Before making your secure payment please email the body shop estimate or insurance company appraisal to contact@stlucieappraisal.net TESLA AND OTHER EXOTIC CAR OWNERS PLEASE CALL FOR RATES.
Service throughout Alabama, Alaska, Arizona, Arkansas, California, Colorado, Connecticut, Delaware, District of Columbia, Florida, Georgia, Hawaii, Idaho, Illinois, Indiana, Iowa, Kansas, Kentucky, Louisiana, Maine, Maryland, Massachusetts, Michigan, Minnesota, Mississippi, Missouri, Montana, Nebraska, Nevada, New Hampshire, New Jersey, New Mexico, New York, North Carolina, North Dakota, Ohio, Oklahoma, Oregon, Pennsylvania, Rhode Island, South Carolina, South Dakota, Tennessee, Texas, Utah, Vermont, Virginia, Washington, West Virginia, Wisconsin and Wyoming
This is an Open Education Resource focused on auto diminished value, collective knowledge and the sharing of scholarly content.
AUTODIMINISHEDVALUE.COM and TOTALLOSSDISPUTE.COM are services of The St. Lucie Appraisal Company.
READ MORE ARTICLES…